Own My Life CEO Natalie Collins speaks on BBC Radio Ulster about Russell Brand, Christian leadership and accountability

Our CEO, Natalie Collins, appeared on BBC Radio Ulster’s Sunday Sequence programme on 15 November, discussing Russell Brand’s conviction for rape and sexual assault, his claims of Christian conversion and the response of Christian leaders who previously welcomed and platformed him.
The conversation raised important questions about the relationship between faith, forgiveness, accountability and the responsibility that comes with public influence. It also highlighted the need for faith communities, across different traditions and expressions, to reflect honestly on how they respond to men's violence against women.
When Christian leaders give men a platform
Brand's highly publicised claims of Christian conversion, including his baptism in 2024 by Christian celebrity Bear Grylls, were welcomed by a number of influential Christian figures. He appeared alongside prominent evangelists and church leaders, some of whom publicly endorsed him and helped introduce him to Christian audiences.
As Natalie, who has a personal Christian faith said to Sunday Sequence, the issue is not whether someone who has caused harm must be precluded from a faith community, or be denied compassion. Christianity has a rich tradition of grace, forgiveness and redemption. The question is what those things mean in practice, particularly when the person claiming a new life has been accused of sexual violence.
In an interview with Premier Christianity (available HERE), Natalie challenged the judgement of Christian leaders who had publicly associated themselves with Brand. She questioned whether they had properly considered the implications of giving him credibility and prominence while serious allegations about his treatment of women were already in the public domain.
She also highlighted the silence of some of the Christian men who had previously been happy to appear alongside Brand. Following his conviction, Natalie told Premier Christianity that she was angry that those who had posed with him had not publicly acknowledged what had happened to the women or reflected on their own decisions. All of these Christian male leaders who had endorsed Russell Brand refused to comment for the Premier article.
This is bigger than evangelical Christian culture
During the BBC discussion, Natalie also highlighted that the questions raised by Brand's platforming are not confined to evangelical Christianity.
She pointed to Greenbelt Festival, the well-known liberal Christian arts and faith festival, which hosted Russell Brand in 2019. His appearance there demonstrates that the need for reflection extends across different Christian traditions and cultures, as his misogyny was well-known even if he had not be charged with sex offences at that time.
It would be too easy for one part of the Church to point the finger at another. The wider Christian community needs to consider how celebrity, charisma, influence, and embracing spirituality or a particular political position can lead organisations and individuals to overlook warning signs and fail to prioritise women who have subjected to abuse.
Whether evangelical, liberal, charismatic or part of another Christian tradition (or any faith tradition!), organisations need to ask difficult questions about their decisions to platform influential men, particularly when allegations of sexual violence have been made.
Christian festival Spring Harvest responds
There are signs that some Christian organisations are beginning to take these questions seriously.
Spring Harvest, one of the UK's largest Christian events, has published a statement following Brand's trial and conviction. Its Board has reviewed individuals invited to speak at the event in light of the case.
The organisation acknowledged the bravery of the women who spoke out and those who continue to come forward. It also recognised the responsibility involved in deciding whom to give a platform to, stating that it continually reviews its speakers and takes action as new information comes to light.
This is an important development in a wider conversation about the responsibility of organisations to exercise discernment and ensure that their platforms are not used to legitimise or elevate people whose actions have caused serious harm.
The great disillusionment: when justice is not enough
Natalie's BBC appearance follows her deeply personal reflection, published on 10 November, entitled The Great Disillusionment.
In it, Natalie explores the complicated emotions surrounding Brand's conviction and the wider disillusionment many women are experiencing.
After decades of campaigning for change, women have seen significant developments in the way sexual violence is understood and prosecuted. The conviction of a famous man for rape and sexual assault might have been expected to feel like a moment of triumph.
But, as Natalie writes, many women do not feel better.
A guilty verdict matters. It establishes accountability and means that a man who has harmed women can be prevented from doing so, at least while he is imprisoned. But it cannot undo the violence, restore what has been destroyed or erase the trauma these men cause.
Natalie reflects on the painful reality that criminal justice is not a panacea for men's violence. Even when justice is achieved, the pain remains.
Drawing on her own experience of abusers and her work supporting women, she writes about the particular anguish of knowing that a man who harmed you may also have harmed other women. There is a painful awareness that the violence did not begin or end with one person.
Natalie draws on theologian Barbara Brown Taylor's understanding of disillusionment as the painful loss of illusions about ourselves, the world and God. Disillusionment can be devastating, but it can also free us to let go of false beliefs and seek what is true.
Natalie's reflection ends with a message to women and girls who have been subjected to men's violence: "We see you. And we've got you."
What does genuine accountability look like?
The conversation about Russell Brand is not simply about one man's claims of religious conversion, or whether his faith is sincere. It is about the responsibilities that come with influence, the difference between private pastoral care and public endorsement, and whether communities are prepared to put the safety and dignity of women before the reputations of powerful men.
Grace must never become a reason to overlook harm. Forgiveness must never be demanded of women, and a public declaration of faith must never be treated as evidence that someone has changed without the accountability, honesty and sustained transformation that genuine change requires.
At Own My Life, we believe women deserve to be believed, supported and enabled to build big and beautiful lives after abuse. What has been done to them must not be sidelined to make room for the redemption stories of the men who harmed them. Whether that takes place in faith communities, the charity sector, film and TV or in families and friendship groups.
Natalie's contribution to BBC Radio Ulster is part of her ongoing commitment to challenging the attitudes, beliefs and structures that enable men's violence, including within faith communities.
We hope this conversation encourages churches, festivals, ministries and Christian organisations of every tradition to reflect on their own responsibilities, listen to women and take seriously the harm caused when influential men are given platforms without proper discernment.
Women matter. Accountability matters. And no man's celebrity, status or religious identity should place him beyond scrutiny.
Listen and read more
AI was used in drafting this article.
.jpg)


Comments